Scaling Strategy
lower-mid-market advisory

Unit Economics Health Check: The 5-Point Diagnostic Before You Scale

Client/Category
Unit Economics
Industry
B2B Tech
Function
Finance & Operations

The "Growth at All Costs" Hangover

For the last decade, the advice to Series B founders was simple: grow. If you grew fast enough, the unit economics would eventually sort themselves out. Capital was cheap, and the market rewarded top-line velocity over bottom-line reality.

That party is over. The lights are on, the music has stopped, and the 2025 market reality is staring you in the face. Investors have swung aggressively from valuing growth to valuing efficient growth. If you are burning $2 to generate $1 of ARR, you aren't building a company; you're building a furnace.

As a founder, you face a critical decision point. You have pressure to scale—to hire the VPs, to ramp the sales team, to expand marketing. But if your underlying unit economics are broken, scaling is the fastest way to kill your company. You don't die from starvation; you die from indigestion.

Before you approve that next headcount plan or sign the insertion order for a new demand gen campaign, you need to pass a health check. This isn't about GAAP accounting; it's about operational physics. If the math doesn't work at $10M ARR, it certainly won't work at $50M.

The 5-Point Unit Economics Diagnostic

We use this exact framework to assess whether a portfolio company is ready for fuel or requires a fix. Grab your latest board deck and let's look at the numbers.

1. CAC Payback Period: The Speed Limit

The Metric: How many months of gross profit it takes to recover the cost of acquiring a customer.

The Benchmark:

  • Great: < 12 months
  • Acceptable: 12–15 months
  • Danger Zone: > 18 months

The Diagnosis: If your payback period is over 18 months, your sales efficiency is toxic. Every new customer you sign digs a deeper cash flow hole that takes a year and a half to fill. Why Your CAC Payback Is Lying to You explores how to audit this number properly (hint: are you including onboarding costs?). Verdict: If >15 months, freeze sales hiring immediately.

2. Net Revenue Retention (NRR): The Leak Detector

The Metric: The percentage of recurring revenue retained from existing customers, including expansion and churn.

The Benchmark:

  • World Class: 130%+
  • Healthy: 110–120%
  • Broken: < 100%

The Diagnosis: In 2025, median NRR has settled near 101–103%, but "median" doesn't get you a premium exit. Healthy companies grow from their installed base. If your NRR is below 100%, you have a hole in the bucket. Pouring more leads into the top (New ARR) is futile until you fix the retention mechanics. See The Valuation Multiplier for deeper NRR targets.

3. Burn Multiple: The Sustainability Index

The Metric: Net Cash Burn divided by Net New ARR. How much cash do you burn to add $1 of revenue?

The Benchmark:

  • Efficient: < 1.0x
  • Sustainable: 1.0x – 1.5x
  • Terminal: > 2.0x

The Diagnosis: This is the ultimate efficiency test. A Burn Multiple of 2.5x means you are spending $2.50 to buy $1.00 of growth. In the zero-interest rate era, this was called "capturing market share." Today, it's called "going out of business." If you are above 1.5x, you need to cut costs or increase velocity—usually both. Check The Efficiency Trap for a detailed breakdown by stage.

4. Gross Margin: The Scalability Test

The Metric: (Revenue - COGS) / Revenue. Note: COGS must include Customer Success and Hosting/DevOps.

The Benchmark:

  • SaaS Target: 75–85%
  • Tech-Enabled Services: 40–50%

The Diagnosis: Be honest about what you are. If you claim to be a SaaS platform but your gross margins are 55%, you are likely a services firm in disguise (using humans to patch product gaps). Low gross margins kill your LTV, which kills your CAC Payback. You cannot scale out of a gross margin problem.

5. ARR per FTE: The Bloat Meter

The Metric: Total ARR divided by total headcount.

The Benchmark:

  • Target at Scale: $200k – $250k
  • Warning Sign: < $150k

The Diagnosis: If you are sitting at $100k ARR/FTE, you have over-hired relative to your traction. This is common after a fresh funding round. The solution isn't always layoffs; it's often a hiring freeze until revenue catches up to the headcount.

If you are burning $2 to generate $1 of ARR, you aren't building a company; you're building a furnace. Operational physics always wins.
Justin Leader
CEO, Human Renaissance

Fix the Inputs Before You Press the Accelerator

If you failed two or more of the checks above, you are not ready to scale. You are in the "Fix" phase.

Scaling a company with broken unit economics amplifies the losses, not the wins. It speeds up the rate at which you hit the wall. The hardest thing for a founder to do is to slow down sales and marketing spend to fix the engine, but it is the only move that preserves optionality.

Your 90-Day Triage Plan

  1. Audit the CAC: Dissect your sales cycle. Where is the friction? If you're spending heavily on paid ads with a 18-month payback, cut the ad spend by 50% and refocus on high-intent channels.
  2. Pricing & Packaging: Often, poor NRR and Gross Margins are pricing problems. Are you charging for the value you deliver? Can you shift service costs to implementation fees to protect recurring margins?
  3. Customer Segmentation: Fire the bad revenue. Some customers cost $2 to support for every $1 they pay. Churning them hurts top-line vanity metrics but saves the company.

The market has shifted. The winners of the next cycle won't be the ones who burned the most cash; they will be the ones who built the most durable revenue engines. Get your unit economics healthy, then pour on the gas.

1.5x
Max Sustainable Burn Multiple (Net Burn / Net New ARR) for Series B
12mo
Target CAC Payback Period for High-Efficiency Growth
Let's improve what matters.
Justin is here to guide you every step of the way.
Citations

We're ready to respond to your doubts

Understanding your habits and bringing future possibilities into the present.